Methodology

How We Review and Score Supplements

One model, seven weighted criteria, applied identically to every product on this site. Published in full so you can check our reasoning — and disagree with it.

The seven criteria

Each criterion is scored on the same 0–5 scale as the final Editorial Rating, and the rating is the weighted average of the seven. Nothing is adjusted per product, per category or per commercial relationship. Each criterion is scored on what the manufacturer and the research have actually published, so two products are always compared on the same material rather than on guesswork.

Ingredient quality

25%

Are the actives ones with a real body of human research behind them, in forms the body can absorb?

Effective dose

20%

Is each active present at an amount studies actually used — and can you tell from the label?

Label transparency

15%

Is the full Supplement Facts panel published before you buy, or printed on the pack?

Third-party testing

15%

Is there independent verification of identity, potency and contaminants?

Brand reputation

10%

How long has the brand existed, how consistently does it describe its products, and how reachable is its support?

Value for money

10%

What does one day of use actually cost at the pack sizes on offer?

Country availability

5%

Can readers in the US, Canada, UK, Australia, New Zealand and Ireland actually order it?

Why label and dose carry the most weight

Label transparency (15%) and effective dose (20%) together make up just over a third of the rating, because a named formula is the easiest thing to check against medication you already take. Where the full composition is printed on the pack rather than the sales page, we rate what the manufacturer has published and point you to the pack — a gap in publication is a reason to read the label on arrival, not a mark against the product.

How we rate evidence levels

Ingredient guides carry an evidence rating separate from any product score. It describes the state of the research on that ingredient, not the quality of a particular bottle.

RatingWhat it meansExamples
Strong Multiple well-designed human trials pointing the same way, ideally including at least one large or independently funded study. Creatine for strength. Protein for muscle preservation. Lutein and zeaxanthin for macular pigment.
Moderate Several human trials with broadly consistent results, or one large trial, usually with some methodological limitations. Bacopa for memory. Curcumin for joint comfort. Berberine for glucose handling.
Limited Small, short or conflicting human trials. Genuinely promising in some cases. Astaxanthin for eye fatigue. Glucosamine for joints. Cinnamon for post-meal glucose.
Early Mostly laboratory or animal work, with human research still at an early stage. Resveratrol for longevity. Lion’s mane for cognition.

What we do not do

Being explicit about our limits is more useful than implying capabilities we do not have.

  • We do not test products in a laboratory. We assess what you can assess before buying. Where a brand publishes independent testing, we credit it.
  • We do not accept payment for a score or a placement. Affiliate links earn commission on sales; they buy nothing else.
  • We do not invent experts. Content is written and checked by the editorial team, credited as an organization. We do not attach a stock photo and a fabricated name to a page.
  • We do not give medical advice. We explain what research shows and where to check further. Decisions about your health belong with you and a qualified professional.

What the scores look like in practice

Every product in the catalogue is rated on the same /5 scale you see on its review. The highest-rated product right now, KaryLief, earns 4.6/5, and the catalogue currently runs from 4.1 to 4.6 out of 5.

4.6

Highest rating /5

KaryLief

4.3

Catalogue average /5

Across 9 products

9

Products rated

Same seven criteria for each

Reading a score

  • 4.4 to 5.0 — Editor’s pick. The strongest all-round profile in its category.
  • 4.2 to 4.3 — Strong option. A well-rounded choice with clear strengths for the reader its review describes.
  • 3.9 to 4.1 — Solid option. A good fit for a specific need, format or budget, set out in its review.

A score is a starting point for your own judgment, not a verdict. The paragraphs around it matter more than the number, which is why every review shows all seven criteria on the same /5 scale.

Commercial relationships

NutraGuide360 is funded by affiliate commission. When you buy through a link here we may earn a percentage, at no extra cost to you. We hold no equity in any brand reviewed, accept no payment for placement or scores, and no brand sees a review before it publishes.

Our affiliate disclosure covers this in full.

Corrections and updates

Prices, availability and formulas change. We re-check every product’s links and published information regularly and update the pages when something moves — a product whose order page stops working is removed rather than left as a dead link. If you find something wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Frequently asked questions

Does affiliate commission affect your scores?
No, and the site itself is the evidence. The criteria and weights are published on this page and applied identically to every product.
Do you test products in a laboratory?
We assess what a buyer can assess before purchasing: the published formula, whether doses match research, what the marketing claims, pack pricing and country availability. If a brand publishes independent testing we credit it.
Why is label transparency weighted so heavily?
Because a named formula is the easiest thing for a reader to check against medication, allergies and published research. Where the full composition is printed on the pack rather than the sales page, we rate what the manufacturer publishes and tell you where to read the rest — a gap in publication is never scored as a defect.